We prefer a thank-you over a small monetary reward

Trivialization Effect (2015)

We prefer a thank-you over a small monetary reward

By acknowledging a customer’s loyalty with a minor financial gift, we shift their perception of the relationship to a trivial, transaction-based one.

Liu, Lamberton, & Haws (2015) Should Firms Use Small Financial Benefits to Express Appreciation to Consumers? Understanding and Avoiding Trivialization Effects, Journal of Marketing

In Summary

  • New research shows that a genuine verbal thank-you makes loyal customers feel more appreciated than a small monetary reward
  • It’s better not to offer any monetary reward than a small one
  • Carry out market research to understand the expected amount your customers think you should gift and reward just above that
  • Those on a tight budget can suppress the effect by reframing the reward or by allowing consumers to donate the small amount

Mr Trivial…

To begin, Dear Reader, consider the following neighbourly scene over the picket fence:

DAVE:
Hey John. It was fun to look after Tiddles while you were away last week.

JOHN:
Thanks Dave. Oh, here, take this dollar bill as a token of my appreciation.

DAVE (To himself):
Okay, this is really weird. Why is he giving me money like this? I thought we were friends…

DAVE:
Erm, thanks John.

(Dave - clearly confused by the offer - reluctantly takes the dollar bill)

JOHN:
No problem. See you soon!

Of course, relationships with one’s friends are different to those with a brand; the transactional basis for such connections being naturally unavoidable.

But consider a recent story, involving Microsoft’s decision to reward Xbox Live Gold members ($60 / year) a special gift of 20 points on their birthday. This sounds great but when you consider that it’s equivalent to $0.25, you can see why there was such a heated response from the gaming community.

This is a great example of what new research calls the Trivialisation Effect - that an over-emphasis on rewarding customers in a minor transactional fashion can dangerously weaken the bond between you and your loyal customer.

Let’s just quickly set the scene regarding thank-yous to consumers.

Trivialization Effect - Illustration 6

A little background on thank-yous

Currently, it’s popular for companies to provide small financial benefits to loyal customers (Lyon 2012; O’Malley 2013), done on the expectation that it’ll make them feel more appreciated (Reis et al. 2000).

So it follows that when gratitude is shared appropriately, consumers will be keen to have a deeper relationship with a firm (Algoe, Fredrickson, and Gable 2013).

But when we add money to a relationship, we start to think about it both in terms of the financial as well as the verbal - a double whammy of expectations, if you will.

Of course, the closer a company is to meeting these expectations around financial rewards, the more satisfied consumers will be (Balakrishnan and Barry 1994)

But companies get it wrong. There’s already research out there showing that we reject “petty” financial rewards (Sunstein, 1996). Accepting them has a negative impact on our performance (Ariely, Bracha, and Meier 2009).

Trivialization Effect - Illustration 5

With all this in mind, let’s now take a look in more detail what the research says, and what to do about it to protect customer loyalty.

Study 1 - The effect itself

49 guests of a hotel conference center were asked for their feedback about their recent stay. All were put into one of two groups, receiving either a verbal thank-you or a financial acknowledgement of $0.05 for their time.

Trivialization Effect - Illustration 1

They were then asked to rate how appreciated they felt. Out of 7, those given a verbal thank you felt an average 5.6 level of appreciation but those given the money felt a far lower 4.4. Sad face.

This robust study shows that customers feel less appreciated with a small monetary gesture over a simple verbal thank you.

Trivialization Effect - Graph 1

Study 2 - How price changes everything

364 people were asked about a clothing store. They were asked to assume that they spend a decent amount of money there, as well as bringing in others to the store. In essence, they were a loyal customer. They were then shown a thank-you email sent to them by the clothing company.

They were put into one of nine groups, varying in the amount of money rewarded within the email.

Trivialization Effect - Illustration 2

After seeing this email, they were asked to rate how appreciated they felt, out of 7. Customers receiving no money felt more appreciated (5.2) than those receiving 5% (4.5) or 10% (5.0) discounts. Naturally, the level of appreciation steadily rose alongside the level of discount given.

This shows that to make customers feel more appreciated, it’s better not to offer a discount at all, than offer a small one. Increasing the reward given will eventually remove the Trivialization Effect, however, which is good news.

Trivialization Effect - Graph 2

Study 3 - How appreciation can be nudged by reframing rewards

A third study provides some fascinating advice on how to change consumers’ perceptions of the reward received, without actually increasing the value of the reward.

251 people were given the same clothing store example as in study 2. The groups this time were simplified into 3: a verbal thank-you, a 5% discount, and a 5% discount shown alongside a range of lower possible discounts.

Trivialization Effect - Illustration 3

And though, when asked how appreciated they felt out of 7, the same results around verbal thank-you being superior (5.08) to the 5% discount (4.25), the 3rd group that saw the lower reward reference points reversed the effect (5.04).

This shows that it’s possible to increase consumers’ sense of appreciation without increasing the amount of money invested into a rewards programme. Merely reframing your existing rewards is enough to make a felt difference.

Trivialization Effect - Graph 3

Study 4 - How appreciation can be increased through donations

Another way to control the effect is to allow consumers to pass on their small financial reward to charity.

238 people were asked to review a furniture website, and were thanked for their feedback, in one of 3 ways: a verbal thank-you, a thank-you and a $0.01 reward, or a thank-you and a $0.01 reward donated to charity.

Trivialization Effect - Illustration 4

The results found that though the $0.01 group felt significantly less appreciated (4.65) than the verbal group (5.48), allowing the reward to be given to charity boosted their feelings (5.14).

This final study shows that it’s possible to increase consumer appreciation without increasing programme investment. By allowing consumers to pass on their minor financial reward to charity, goodwill and a sense of giving is fostered. Note that this is still lower than the verbal reward, but its effects are still clear to see.

Ultimately, rewarding loyal customers is not as straightforward as it might seem. A small financial thank-you can harm your relationship, and it would be more loyalty-optimal to either just thank them, increase, reframe or allow for it to be given away, fostering a Noble Edge Effect.

And so with this gem now written, I sincerely thank you for taking the time to read it.

🙇

Takeaways for decision-makers

  1. Know that communicating simple, genuine verbal appreciation to customers that conforms to verbal norms is incredibly important for your brand (Lambert, Graham, and Fincham 2009).
  2. A verbal thank-you is preferred by customers over a similarly-phrased financial gesture, as long as it sounds natural (study 2b) and where the money received is smaller than expected.
  3. Carry out a round of market research on your customers to understand what their expected levels of financial reward are. Indeed, Money can be beneficial in acknowledging loyalty, but being aware of how much is crucial. Offer something above what your research states in order to reverse the Trivialization Effect.
  4. Reframe perceptions of the reward: show it on a scale, with the reward given at the highest end shown. This will change the reference point of the reward, increasing felt appreciation and perceived reward value.
  5. Offer members the option to donate their monetary reward to charity. There are many other benefits for pro-social companies (Varadarajan and Menon 1988), but the research shows that doing this more effectively communicates the firm’s thank you gesture.